top of page

Reads: "In Defense of Food"

Oct 30, 2022
5 min read

Hello friends! I'm not the type who loves a long intro (thank goodness for the "jump to recipe" buttons on food blogs) but I do want to take a moment to acknowledge that this is my first ever post. I started this blog to have a productive outlet for my climate anxiety, and I hope that it can also be a way to share all my sustainable findings with others. In the end it doesn't really matter if anyone is reading this, but if you are, I just want to say thanks for joining me!


With that out of the way, I'm so excited to talk about this book. If you’re not already familiar, here’s a brief overview. Author Michael Pollan opens the book with a manifesto starting with just a few words: “Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.” He starts the first of the three major sections of the book with a scrutinization of the "Western Diet" that most Americans eat today, noting that we have the highest rates of heart disease, diabetes, and obesity in the world. He traces the origins of this diet back to the mid-twentieth century when rates of heart disease began to rise and scientists started to practice "nutritionsim" over nutrition in an attempt to improve our health. He then continues onto the next section to explain that the mass production of "food-like substances" full of targeted health claims began to replace real foods in the supermarkets, thus furthering the Western Diet's hold on society with no health improvements in sight. In conclusion, he tells eaters how to escape the Western Diet and its coinciding list of diseases, and how we can adjust our mindset of diet and health. If you're at all intrigued by my attempted synopsis of this highly complex topic, I highly recommend you read this book. Fair warning, it reads very academic (I'll admit to falling asleep a few times), but it offered me several new insights into food and culture that I had never previously considered.


One of the perspectives that I found incredibly poignant involves societal diet culture and "health". For some brief context: I grew up in a house free of fad diets and full of nourishing, home-cooked meals, so I've always had a good relationship with food. Despite this, the constant messaging of low-fat and low-carb foods being "healthier" still managed to reach me through media, and continues to influence my decision-making at the grocery store on a deeply subconscious level. Pollan makes the case that fats and carbs don't matter all that much when it comes to a healthy diet. He then compares diets of several older and more traditional cultures around the globe that are considered to be "healthy" and finds completely different consumption levels of fats, carbs, proteins, fruits and veggies, and dairy. He concludes that the only thing these "healthy" diets do have in common is the abundance of real foods and the lack of packaged "food-like substances."


Another idea that really blew me away was Pollan's proclamation that how we eat is just as important as what we eat. He utilizes the French diet to demonstrate that what they eat is the exact opposite of what Americans believe to be "healthy". They eat foods high in fat, high in carbs, and they drink a lot of alcohol. However, he then argues that how the French eat is also the exact opposite of American culture. They eat meals in communal settings and they take their time, usually not leaving the table until hours after everyone sits down. Pollan makes the case that these two simple actions would improve our relationship with food and should be viewed as more important than following certain diets.


This book was so eye opening and informative, and I'm already brainstorming how I can apply what I've learned. I currently purchase most of my groceries from the perimeter of the store, but I do venture to the center to buy items like granola, sauces, and the occasional box of brownie mix. However, after learning just how much these "food-like substances" are harming our health, it's all the more reason to make from scratch as much as I possibly can. I also noticed that I still automatically selected the 0% fat Greek yogurt during my last trip to the grocery, but perhaps next time I'll consider trying the 2% to see if I enjoy it more. In addition to considering what I eat, I've also reflected on how I eat and I'm almost embarrassed by the two usual scenarios; the first being that I scarf down my meal in a manner of minutes, or that I eat while completing some mundane task in front of my computer. In either case, I'm not taking the time or effort to actually enjoy the meal in front of me. I've already vowed to myself that for at least one meal a day, I will have no distractions, I will take time to actually chew my food, and that I will savor it.


Now, you may be thinking to yourself, “Caroline, this book doesn’t sound very focused on sustainability.” And you’d be mostly right, because the book is mostly focused on the topics I’ve written about. However, Pollan does touch on detrimental environmental effects of conventional farming and ranching practices, and strongly advocates that eaters focus on purchasing organic produce and pasture-raised animal products (if you’re an omnivore) where they can for the health benefits as well. I’m certainly not an expert, but I would also assume that the reduction of eating these “food-like substances” would also perhaps cut down on food packaging waste and emissions from processing plants. A win-win situation if you ask me!


If you decide to In Defense of Food, I hope it's as interesting and encouraging for you as it was for me! Additionally, if you do decide to read it, here's how I recommend accessing a copy as an alternative to a *certain* massive online retailer.


- check if it's available at your local library, either physically or digitally

- call or visit the website of your local bookstore, even if they don't have a copy immediately available they might be able to order it for you

- ask around your family and friend groups to see if you can borrow someone's copy

- order online at indiebound.org, a network of hundreds of independent bookstores made accessible online


When you finish it, or if you have already read it, I'd love to hear what you thought! Please feel free to leave comments on what resonated with you, what changed your mindset, and if you have any other recommendations on this topic. I love a good discussion!


Happy reading,

Caroline



Recent Posts

See All
Caroline Tries: Composting

Hey friends! Today’s post is all about composting! Although it’s been a bit of a journey for me to get started, it feels good to finally...

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

proudly created with wix.com

bottom of page